Hmm how about we start with a closed prompt where they talk a bit and where the hostage taking first happens, then move on to a separate joint TL where Hiccup is free to keep talking to everyone since he'll probably have his limbs bound, but not gagged? If you don't mind a bit of injury she totally would make a show of it making a tiny cut to draw blood at his neck, but by the time he's free and get his hands back, won't feel any lingering wound on his neck at all as if there's nothing there even if he's SURE he was lightly cut?

...Since things REALLY escalated in the server chat today everyone could WTF at the mauling session once it happens later down the thread? This is definitely happening with how much SPICE it's bringing to the table, God. Sorry Hiccup you are absolutely walking out of this more traumatized than Ciel herself is...